InCommon Technical Discussions

[Scott Koranda <>]

> Since this is a functional requirement instead of a technical requirement, 
> I think it's useful to ask what we are trying to accomplish. Is it so that 
> the logo renders well?
> 
> If so, I think that instead of putting a requirement, it would be
> useful to pull together a page for the logo designers to help them
> understand the situations when the logo might be used, and then let
> designers resolve that problem. As opposed to making it part of the
> requirement.

I strongly disagree.

That leads to the completely dysfunctional situation we have today
across eduGAIN. It is so bad that for my projects we now spend the time
to hand-craft logos for the institutions involved in the project
ourselves because the images provided by the community are, taken
together, unusable.

Please consider what the SPs are asking (begging) for..

Scott K for LIGO